How to Decide When to Retire or Change a KPI

by Stacey Barr |

KPIs or performance measures are like clothes: they each have a certain fit, use, purpose and lifetime. But it’s usually quite more obvious when to retire a garment than it is to retire a KPI.


There will never be one perfect set of KPIs for your business or organisation or team or process. That’s because the context or environment in which we’re measuring is always changing. And it changes what is meaningful to measure.

Different things that make up context naturally change, like:

  • our customers and what they want
  • our skill and experience in how to measure
  • our performance capability
  • our knowledge about what works and what doesn’t in our organisation
  • our understanding of our true purpose

Changes like these become triggers for changes in what we measure, as time goes by. Their cadence won’t always be the same; it won’t always be an annual event to review our measures. We should review our measures when any of the following things happen:

  • the strategic goals have changed
  • our team goals have changed
  • a measure’s target has been achieved (and now it’s performance is monitored only for exceptions, not improvement)
  • we realise the measure isn’t a good match for the goal
  • we realise that the measure isn’t a real measure (it’s a milestone or an activity or just too vague to be quantified)
  • the measure is driving the wrong behaviour (data manipulation, etc…)
  • improving the measure’s result is triggering unintended consequences that can’t be mitigated (like reducing cycle time triggering an increase in accidents)

To review a measure, should one of these triggers happen, we need to do more than just brainstorm a new one. We need to go back to its purpose first.

If you’re a PuMP user, this means going back to Step 2 (with the Measurability Tests and Results Map) to make sure you have a meaningfully measurable goal. And then doing Step 3 (with the Measure Design template) to create a really good replacement measure.

If you’re not a PuMP user, then read this article about making goals measurable and this article about designing meaningful measures. Or come and learn PuMP! 😉

So reviewing our measures is a natural and useful thing to do. But don’t make it a bureaucratic activity. Look out for the triggers of when to do it sensibly. We want our collection of measures, at any point in time, to be the most useful information we can muster.


What triggers have you relied on to review your measures? Do you have any before-and-after examples to share?


Speak Your Mind

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Upcoming KPI Training

    Our next PuMP Performance Measure Blueprint Workshops include:

    >> Australia/NZ/Asia Pacific, Online Interactive, 6-7, 11-13 Oct 2021 *REGISTRATION CLOSED*

    >> Africa, Online Interactive, 11-15 Oct 2021

    >> United Kingdom, Online Interactive 5, 12, 19, 26 Nov & 3 Dec 2021

    >> Australia/NZ/Asia Pacific, Online Interactive, 10-11, 15-17 Nov 2021

    >> North America, Online Interactive, 15-19 Nov 2021

    >> Africa, Online Interactive, 14-18 Mar 2022

    >> Africa, Online Interactive, 20-24 Jun 2022

    >> Africa, Online Interactive, 26-30 Sep 2022

    >> Africa, Online Interactive, 28 Nov - 2 Dec 2022

    Register for the next PuMP Blueprint Workshop near you

    Stacey's Books

    Prove It! How to Create a High-Performance Culture and Measurable Success, book by Stacey Barr

    Order Prove It! here.

    Practical Performance Measurement: Using the PuMP Blueprint For Fast, Easy, And Engaging KPIs, book by Stacey Barr

    Order Practical Performance Measurement here.

    Reprinting Articles

    You are welcome to use articles from the Measure Up blog, with these requirements

    Connect with Stacey

    Haven’t found what you’re looking for? Want more information? Fill out the form below and I’ll get in touch with you as soon as possible.

      *We respect your email privacy.
      Level 54, 111 Eagle Street
      Brisbane, Qld, 4000
      Stacey Barr Pty Ltd
      ACN: 129953635
      Director: Stacey Barr